Advanced search options

Advanced Search Options 🞨

Browse by author name (“Author name starts with…”).

Find ETDs with:

in
/  
in
/  
in
/  
in

Written in Published in Earliest date Latest date

Sorted by

Results per page:

You searched for id:"oai:etd.ohiolink.edu:osu156268632958823". One record found.

Search Limiters

Last 2 Years | English Only

No search limiters apply to these results.

▼ Search Limiters


The Ohio State University

1. Fritz, James Christopher. Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action.

Degree: PhD, Philosophy, 2019, The Ohio State University

This dissertation develops and defends a view of the relationship between knowledge and norms on action. The view I defend is an impurist one; on this view, whether a person knows that p can depend on factors that are unrelated to the truth or likelihood of p. On my impurism, normative facts about actions and options—including, for instance, the costs of relying on a belief in action—are among the non-truth-related factors that can make a difference to knowledge. My view is distinctive, in part, because of the further claim that moral facts about actions and options are among the normative considerations that can make a difference to knowledge. In a slogan: epistemic norms are sensitive to moral considerations. In an even shorter slogan: there is moral encroachment in epistemology. The first half of the dissertation defends the claim that there is moral encroachment in epistemology. In chapter 1 (“Pragmatic Encroachment and Moral Encroachment”), I argue that moral encroachment is at least as well-motivated as a more familiar view: the view that there is pragmatic encroachment in epistemology. In chapter 2 (“Uncertainty, Belief, and Ethical Weight”), I draw on insights from moral psychology to provide an original argument for moral encroachment.The second half of the dissertation starts from the assumption that there is moral encroachment in epistemology. It is devoted to describing in detail how moral encroachment works. In chapter 3 (“Moral Encroachment and Reasons of the Wrong Kind”), I distinguish between a radical and a moderate version of moral encroachment. I raise a problem for the radical version: it threatens to erase the distinction between epistemic and non-epistemic norms on belief. This problem, I note, does not afflict the moderate version of moral encroachment. In chapter 4 (“Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action”), I show that it is no trivial task to explain why knowledge is sensitive to both moral norms and norms of practical coherence. In fact, I argue, existing versions of impurism generally lack the resources to provide the needed explanation. I also make some suggestions about the best ways to for an impurist to meet this challenge.It’s clear that impurists both can and should add texture to their picture of norms on action. They can make significant headway by endorsing two of my primarily conclusions. First: there are multiple distinct families of normative considerations (including, for instance, moral considerations and considerations of practical coherence) that are equally well-placed to make a difference to knowledge. And second: only some of the moral considerations that bear on belief are apt to make a difference to knowledge. These conclusions point the way toward a clearer picture of an impurism worth defending. Advisors/Committee Members: McPherson, Tristram (Advisor).

Subjects/Keywords: Philosophy; Epistemology; impurism; pragmatic encroachment; moral encroachment

Record DetailsSimilar RecordsGoogle PlusoneFacebookTwitterCiteULikeMendeleyreddit

APA · Chicago · MLA · Vancouver · CSE | Export to Zotero / EndNote / Reference Manager

APA (6th Edition):

Fritz, J. C. (2019). Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action. (Doctoral Dissertation). The Ohio State University. Retrieved from http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu156268632958823

Chicago Manual of Style (16th Edition):

Fritz, James Christopher. “Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action.” 2019. Doctoral Dissertation, The Ohio State University. Accessed November 17, 2019. http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu156268632958823.

MLA Handbook (7th Edition):

Fritz, James Christopher. “Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action.” 2019. Web. 17 Nov 2019.

Vancouver:

Fritz JC. Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action. [Internet] [Doctoral dissertation]. The Ohio State University; 2019. [cited 2019 Nov 17]. Available from: http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu156268632958823.

Council of Science Editors:

Fritz JC. Knowledge and the Many Norms on Action. [Doctoral Dissertation]. The Ohio State University; 2019. Available from: http://rave.ohiolink.edu/etdc/view?acc_num=osu156268632958823

.